You Can't Regulate What You Can't See: The Missing Piece in Britain's Housing Reforms

Britain has developed a remarkable appetite for regulating its housing market. Every few months, another piece of legislation, proposed reform or government initiative arrives promising to improve standards, protect consumers or make the system work more efficiently. Some of those ambitions are entirely sensible, while others deserve considerably more scrutiny. But there's one rather fundamental question that seems to get overlooked in all the excitement: how exactly are we supposed to enforce all these rules when we still struggle to access reliable information about the properties themselves?

It's a question that came up during a fascinating conversation I recently had with Nitin Agarwal, founder of Property Deal Insights (PDI), on The Viking Chats. Nitin spent much of his career working on enormous technology programmes in financial services before turning his attention to the rather less sophisticated world of British property data. What struck me wasn't simply the scale of what he's building, but the extraordinary contrast between how other industries use information to make decisions and how much of our property market still operates.

We've Got Plenty of Data. We Just Can't Use It Properly.

Nitin explained that PDI brings together information relating to more than 34 million UK properties. That's an enormous amount of information covering everything from valuations and planning to energy efficiency, flood risks, broadband availability and leasehold considerations. But the interesting part isn't the number of properties. It's the fact that this information already exists in various forms, scattered across numerous sources, organisations and systems, often with very little connection between them.

Our problem isn't necessarily a shortage of information. It's the fragmented, inconsistent and often inaccessible nature of that information. We're dealing with assets worth hundreds of thousands, sometimes millions, of pounds, yet establishing a reliable picture of an individual property's characteristics, risks and obligations can still require considerable manual investigation. Different parties collect different pieces of information, different systems store it and different professionals interpret it. Far too often, someone ends up paying another person to find information that somebody else has already collected.

It's an extraordinarily inefficient way to run an industry that plays such a significant role in the national economy. And while we've become very good at talking about digital transformation, there's still an awful lot of work being done that amounts to little more than moving information from one place to another.

More Legislation Doesn't Automatically Mean Better Housing

There's an understandable tendency among politicians to respond to problems by introducing new rules. Poor property conditions? Introduce stronger standards. Unfair treatment of tenants? Strengthen their rights. Concerns about landlord behaviour? Add further obligations and penalties. On paper, much of this sounds perfectly reasonable, particularly when the objective is to protect people who might otherwise find themselves in vulnerable situations.

But legislation only achieves its intended purpose when somebody can identify non-compliance, establish the relevant facts and take appropriate action. Without that capability, even well-intentioned legislation risks becoming little more than another obligation that responsible operators spend time and money meeting, while those determined to ignore the rules continue doing precisely that. We can keep expanding the rulebook, but unless we improve our ability to identify problems and enforce the standards we've established, we're unlikely to achieve the improvements we're looking for.

This is particularly relevant to the private rented sector. Professional letting agents and responsible landlords already navigate an extensive collection of legal responsibilities covering property safety, deposit protection, licensing, documentation, maintenance obligations and an increasingly complex framework governing tenancy management. The people who take those responsibilities seriously aren't necessarily the people causing the problems that additional legislation is supposed to address, yet they're often the ones carrying the greatest immediate administrative burden.

If we're genuinely interested in raising standards across the sector, surely we need to become considerably better at identifying where those standards aren't being met. That requires reliable information, sensible connections between systems and the ability to distinguish genuine problems from the enormous amount of routine activity taking place across millions of tenancies.

The Property Industry's Information Problem Starts Long Before a Tenancy

One of the most interesting aspects of Nitin's work concerns the buying and selling process. PDI is involved in initiatives around digital property information and upfront disclosure, bringing together material that buyers, sellers, agents, lenders and conveyancers need to make informed decisions. It's difficult to argue against the principle, particularly when you consider how much time and money can be wasted discovering important information long after a transaction has started.

Why should a buyer discover significant information about a property months after making an offer, when much of that information could potentially have been available before the property was marketed? Leasehold restrictions, service charges, planning considerations and environmental risks can all materially affect a purchasing decision. Discovering them late creates unnecessary uncertainty, delays and, sometimes, transactions collapsing entirely. Nitin's argument is straightforward: give everyone access to the relevant facts earlier, and people can make better decisions.

That principle doesn't stop being relevant when somebody collects the keys. The rental market has its own version of exactly the same problem, with information collected during marketing, referencing, tenancy creation, property management, compliance checks and, eventually, the conclusion of the tenancy. Yet the connections between those stages are frequently remarkably poor, even when an agency has invested heavily in the systems intended to support them.

An agent might have detailed information about a property's condition, its inventory, previous maintenance, compliance history and tenancy documentation. But when that information is needed for a particular decision, it can still involve searching through emails, opening multiple systems and manually reconstructing events. The information exists, but turning it into something immediately useful remains far more difficult than it should be. For an industry that spends so much time talking about efficiency, that's a fairly significant contradiction.

The Renters' Rights Changes Expose a Bigger Operational Challenge

During our conversation, Nitin and I discussed how changes to tenancy structures are affecting the way letting agencies operate. For years, much of the industry worked around relatively predictable fixed-term tenancy cycles. Agents could anticipate renewals, organise marketing activity and forecast a reasonable proportion of their income around those established patterns. Moving towards a more flexible tenancy landscape changes that dynamic, creating new questions about when tenants might leave, when properties should be marketed and how rental income and workloads might fluctuate throughout the year.

Nitin described how PDI is working with agency groups on predictive modelling, rental evidence and market intelligence to support decisions in this changing environment. It's a useful illustration of why data infrastructure matters beyond regulatory compliance. When the underlying rules of an industry change, businesses that can understand emerging patterns and respond quickly have an obvious advantage over those relying entirely on historical assumptions.

That doesn't mean technology can predict every tenant's behaviour. People are wonderfully unpredictable, particularly when it comes to their homes, and no algorithm is going to eliminate that uncertainty entirely. But better information can help businesses distinguish between a genuine emerging trend and a handful of unusual experiences that happen to dominate the office conversation. In an industry where so many operational decisions are still based on instinct, that would represent meaningful progress.

AI Won't Fix Bad Information

Naturally, we also discussed artificial intelligence. It would be rather difficult to have a conversation about the future of property technology without somebody mentioning AI within the first ten minutes, and there are some genuinely exciting opportunities. AI could make it substantially easier to interpret complex information, identify inconsistencies, prepare documentation, support compliance checks and reduce the administrative work that consumes so much of an agent's day.

But there's an important distinction between having a clever tool and having the reliable information required to make that tool useful. If the underlying property data is incomplete, outdated or disconnected, adding an AI interface doesn't magically solve the problem. It might simply allow us to produce questionable answers considerably faster, which isn't quite the technological revolution anyone was hoping for.

This is why I found Nitin's approach particularly interesting. Rather than trying to build every possible application that might use property information, PDI increasingly focuses on supplying the underlying data infrastructure to other businesses. Different platforms can then build services on top of a common foundation of property intelligence, making it easier to develop useful tools without every company having to solve the same information problems independently.

That approach makes a great deal of sense to me. The property industry doesn't necessarily need another hundred disconnected applications, each maintaining its own slightly different version of the same information. It needs better connections between the systems that already exist, alongside a willingness from technology providers to collaborate rather than insist that every customer moves into their particular ecosystem.

The Best Technology Should Make the Work Disappear

At The Depositary, we've spent years examining what happens when a tenancy comes to an end. It's an incredibly revealing part of the rental process because so many of the inefficiencies that have accumulated throughout the tenancy suddenly become visible. Information has to be gathered, evidence reviewed, decisions communicated and, where appropriate, deductions agreed or disputed. Often, the difficulty isn't that the information was never recorded, but that finding, interpreting and presenting it requires far more effort than it should.

This is why I keep coming back to the same principle: good technology should remove unnecessary work rather than simply digitise it. Taking a complicated manual process and putting it on a screen isn't necessarily transformation. Real progress comes when systems communicate, information is available at the right moment and professionals can focus their attention on decisions that genuinely require their expertise.

The same principle applies whether you're producing an upfront property information pack, assessing a rental valuation, managing compliance or concluding a tenancy. If we already know something about a property, why should somebody have to find it, enter it or verify it all over again? Obviously, information needs to remain accurate and appropriate for its intended use, but the starting point should be making existing, reliable information work harder.

There's a Difference Between Being Data-Led and Being Data-Obsessed

I don't believe every letting agent needs to become a data scientist. Nor do I think the answer to every problem is another dashboard displaying seventeen different performance indicators. There's a danger that the technology industry occasionally forgets what the people using its products are actually trying to achieve, particularly when suppliers become more interested in demonstrating their technical capabilities than solving the problems their customers face.

Letting agents want to manage properties effectively, keep their clients informed, protect their businesses and deliver a good service. Landlords want confidence that their investments are being managed responsibly. Tenants want safe, well-maintained homes and a fair, straightforward experience. Data is valuable because it helps deliver those outcomes, and its usefulness should ultimately be judged by whether it makes those experiences better.

The challenge for technology providers is to make sophisticated information useful without expecting the end user to understand the complexity sitting behind it. A well-designed system should make a complicated task feel simple, with the hard work happening in the background. That's where I think the most meaningful progress will come over the next few years, particularly as agencies face growing pressure to deliver more without endlessly increasing their headcount.

We Need to Build the Infrastructure, Not Just Keep Changing the Rules

There's no shortage of ambition when it comes to improving Britain's housing market. We want higher standards, faster transactions, better consumer protection, greater transparency and a more professional rental sector. Those are worthwhile objectives, and I suspect most people working in property would welcome genuine progress towards them, even if we disagree about the best way to get there.

But we need to become much more serious about the infrastructure required to deliver those ambitions. That means reliable property information, better-connected systems, sensible data standards and processes designed around how people actually work. It also means recognising that legislation, however well intentioned, cannot compensate for an industry that struggles to identify and share the information needed to implement it.

Nitin's journey from financial services technology into property is a reminder that many of the problems we accept as normal aren't necessarily inevitable. Other sectors have spent decades investing in infrastructure that allows enormous volumes of complex information to move securely and efficiently between organisations. Property has some catching up to do, and the growing involvement of businesses focused on underlying data infrastructure suggests that this is finally receiving the attention it deserves.

Perhaps the most important shift we can make is to stop asking how much more regulation the industry needs and start asking whether we've built the systems required to make the regulation we already have genuinely effective. Because you can't regulate what you can't see, and you certainly can't improve what you don't properly understand.

Next
Next

The Compliance Tipping Point: Why Letting Agents Can't Keep Doing Everything Manually